Date: 8th June 2011 at 3:29pm
Written by:

Alan Smith is once again being linked with a move back to Leeds United after being told by Newcastle that he is surplus to requirements.

Smith is probably the most talked about player from the David O`Leary squad, who moved on to those from across the Pennines (TFATP) when Leeds hit the financial buffers in 2004.

Despite the move now being seven years ago, the Alan Smith debate often rages across the Leeds United fans sites with the boyhood Leeds fan seeming to have the ‘Marmite` effect amongst Leeds fans, they either still love him or hate him.

Since the news broke on Tuesday that Newcastle were ready to offload Smith, the Leeds forums have been in overdrive, as the discussion that seems to pop up every transfer window once again rears its head

There seems to be no in between, there are those fans that can never forgive him for moving to Leeds biggest rivals back in 2004. It has also been rumoured that he once kissed the badge of (TFATP), which further infuriated the fans of Leeds.

I cannot say whether this is true or untrue, as I would rather have my eyes torn out than have to sit and watch 90 minutes of (TFATP).

A number of clubs were chasing Smith in the summer of 2004, but it`s seen as unforgivable by one section of Leeds supporters.

On the other hand, there are those that believe he joined (TFATP) as they were the only club at the time that were willing to stump up the cash in full, rather than stagger the payments back to Elland Road. Again this is another rumour that as never been proved.

Also, if the other ten players on the pitch during Leeds relegation season of 2003/04 had rolled their sleeves up and been prepared to fight as Smith did in every game they wouldn`t have been relegated.

Leeds still had a squad of players that shouldn`t have been struggling in the relegation places, but the fact that they knew they could hide behind the off field problems and the fact they knew they were going to move on and stay in the Premiership at the end of the season, saw most of them not giving 100%.

I think the fans feelings towards Smith were shown when Leeds travelled to Newcastle for a pre season friendly in 2009.

It`s the only occasion that Smith as lined up against Leeds since his departure and he was subjected to boo`s throughout the game.

We can now look at the likelihood of Smith actually coming back to Leeds.

He is still in contract at St James` Park, so Newcastle are going to want a fee for his services, a player that cost them in the region of £6 million in 2007.

The chances of him leaving for a figure less than seven figures, are one reason why it would be doubtful that he would return to Leeds, as they haven`t signed a player for anywhere near that value in the past nine years.

Smith is rumoured to be one of Newcastle`s highest earners, so unless he is prepared to take a huge pay cut, this is another reason why he will not return this summer.
Leeds chairman Ken Bates has had his say, saying that it would depend on the players fitness and wage demands.

The 30 year old has also struggled with injury since his departure from Elland Road.

The striker as started just 138 games in 7 seasons and he made just 10 starts for Newcastle in the Premier League last season.

However, in reality, will Leeds spend over £1 million on a player? – No.
Will they break their salary cap? Something that Leeds have so rigidly stuck by in recent seasons – No.
In the very unlikely event that they were willing to do this, would they gamble it all on a 30 year old, who is despised by a large section of the clubs supporters and as averaged less than 20 starts a season since leaving in 2004 – No.

They only way that Smith will return to Leeds are if he is willing to take a huge pay cut.

Smith has always said he loves the club, some fans will take some winning over but I am sure a few stirring performances and a player in the middle of the park willing to put every thing on the line in a Leeds shirt (how we missed one of those last season) would soon get the fans back onside.

The ball is in your court Alan Smith.

Join The Vital Debate

Vital Leeds are the proud sponsors of the Thames Valley Whites Regional Supporters club

The fastest growing Leeds United supporters club in the South of England, with almost 200 members since it`s formation in April 2009, travel to all games home and away.

The branch has pick up points at Basingstoke, Reading, Didcot, Abingdon, Oxford, Bicester and Banbury and will consider other pick up points on request.

Vital Leeds offers everything that a Leeds United supporter could wish for. If you can think of something and suggest it, we`ll put it on the website!

With news and views, along with a forum, polls and article comments, everything you need in a fans site is right here!

You can even win prizes, by posting articles comments, posting on the message forum and voting on the polls.

The site is regularly updated with news and views regarding all the current events at Elland Road, alongside a fully interactive message forum.

With news and views, along with a forum, polls and article comments, everything you need in a fans site is right here!

You can even win prizes, by posting articles comments, posting on the message forum and voting on the polls.

Vital is also 100% interactive. Not only can you have your say on the articles and the forum but you can also suggest an article or a poll so you can air your views.

So why not join Vital today?

It’s easy to register here and enjoy getting involved

Message Board

To visit the message board, click here.

Get involved

This website is your website and we are looking for people to help run the site. Do you go to most of the games and have an opinion? Why not write a match report? Perhaps you are a budding journalist or even just someone who is very opinionated? Well why not join our team? If this interests you please contact Vital Leeds .

Bookmark and Share

Vital Leeds is now available on both facebook and twitter, so if you are that way inclined and more importantly understand all this new fangled dangled stuff, feel free to watch us, poke us or whatever else you are meant to do there!

Vital Leeds on: facebook

Vital Leeds on: twitter


Your Comment